The (historical past of) spice should stream
To me, one of the intriguing objects housed within the Metropolitan Museum of Fashionable Artwork in New York is a container for one thing that few folks have ever heard of: the lapis de Goa, or “Goa stone.”
Goa stones had been a compound of gold, crushed gems, herbs, bezoars, and different unique substances standard within the 1690-1750 interval. Just like the bezoars they imitated, they had been thought to supply a strong safety in opposition to poisoning. Tiny flakes could be shaved off and consumed (I image them being dropped in wine glasses) by rich customers in India and Europe. As you may little doubt inform from the extremely lavish ornament of this explicit Goa stone container, they had been extraordinarily beneficial.
Final week, in “Why drug history?”, I argued for the usefulness of medication and spices for serving to us to higher perceive necessary features of human historical past. However apart from mentioning Paul Freedman’s nice ebook Out of the East: Spices and the Medieval Imagination, I didn’t dig a lot into the spice commerce per se.
That is partly as a result of I are inclined to subsume spices into the class of medication. I agree with Freedman’s strategy of seeing spices, herbs, medicinal animal merchandise, and even gems as all occupying the identical amorphous class within the medieval and early fashionable durations. They had been all medicinal simples, the uncooked supplies out of which medication had been made.
As Freedman explains, spices had been a class of simples that moved fluidly between the culinary and medical realms:
All of those substances—crops, animal merchandise, gems— had been ‘simples’ and could possibly be mixed to type numerous compounds. Pharmacists needed to know the right way to grind up mixtures of simples in keeping with medical directions or their very own ingenuity. Pounding and grinding collectively these fragrant merchandise was a tedious process and have become a logo of the artwork and labor of the medical or culinary skilled in spices, the prepare dinner and the pharmacist. The mortar, an emblem of subtle cooking within the Center Ages due to its use in grinding spices, has remained the preeminent image of pharmacists, simply because the phrase ‘recipe’ in most languages means each directions for cooks and prescriptions for druggists, a reminder of the conceptual similarity of the 2 professions.
It’s not onerous to see the blurring between the culinary and the medical if you happen to learn premodern writings about medication. In my first ebook The Age of Intoxication, as an example, I cite the case of Bahadur, a sultan of sixteenth century Gujarat who (in keeping with the Portuguese doctor Garcia de Orta) ate a type of candy, spiced sweet composed of sugar, nutmeg, mace, camphor, opium, and hashish which supposedly allowed him “to go to Portugal or Brazil or Turkey or Arabia or Persia” through hallucinatory, drug-induced goals.
As a child, I bear in mind our historical past class that includes a module on the spice commerce by which we discovered about its significance to the Silk Street, together with a lot of enjoyable trivia about issues just like the Biblical significance of frankincense and myrrh and the truth that nutmeg initially solely grew on one small island chain. However it wasn’t till I grew to become knowledgeable historian that I spotted simply how foundational the starvation for spices has been in human historical past. The commerce routes of the Indian Ocean world, as an example, are among the many most long-lasting and vital long-distance commerce hyperlinks in human historical past.
And if you happen to dig into their origins roughly three to 4 thousand years in the past, you discover… cinnamon.
Cinnamon and cassia retailers, and later different merchants in spices, had been the pioneers of the Indian Ocean commerce routes linking Southeast Asia to the Pink Sea.
By the Roman interval, the commerce between India and the Mediterranean had diversified fairly a bit. Besides — as this map based mostly on an necessary 1st century Greco-Roman major supply signifies— spices and medicines had been nonetheless on the heart of issues.
One of many massive questions that motivates my very own analysis into the historical past of medication and spices is… why? Why did so many thousands and thousands of people, over 1000’s of years of historical past, danger their lives to move these kinds of unique substances — that are clearly not necessities of human life — over lengthy distances? Why did folks need them a lot?
Right here Ruth Benedict — the famed cultural anthropologist who was an necessary mentor of Margaret Mead’s — may also help us. Benedict’s necessary function in rethinking the historical past and anthropology of visionary states normally (and drug-induced states specifically) is mentioned on web page 23 of my just-published ebook Tripping on Utopia:
Ruth Benedict’s 1922 article “The Imaginative and prescient in Plains Tradition” (one of many works that impressed Mead to turn out to be an anthropologist) had supplied an particularly influential new perspective on peyote. Western scientists, Benedict famous, assumed that altered states of consciousness lowered the capability for thought—that they had been a type of intoxication. However what if the pursuit of visionary states was, in some cultures, a constructive objective? In these “Dionysian” cultures, as she dubbed them, visionary or trance states supplied a supply of recent data, mutual understanding, and social cohesion, not an escape into fantasy.
Medication which induce altered states of consciousness or altered experiences of the world, in different phrases, have performed an necessary (and, crucially, a constructive) cultural function in lots of societies around the globe. The sultan Bahadur, in spite of everything, was not a stigmatized member of an out group. He was, properly… the sultan.
However after all, most medication and spices which have performed a significant function in world historical past don’t alter psychological states in something just like the ways in which opium or peyote do. They’re extra like nutmeg, sugar, or tea: barely mood-altering, maybe. Intriguing, actually. However not pathways to visionary states, or, for that matter, to the curing of a illness.
For these substances, the work of Paul Freedman on the medieval spice commerce is very useful. Within the chapter in Out of the East which focuses on “Spices as Medication,” he writes:
Though medical consultants likened their putative occult and (when it comes to the science of the period) inexplicable results to the motion of a magnet in attracting iron, spices do not appear to have been as dependable, as proven by the multiplicity of typically contradictory recipes. That is necessary, not merely to point out the deficiencies of medieval pharmacology, which are actually self-evident, however to get an thought of what folks thought medicines may do and what they had been for. It isn’t as apparent as saying that spices cured or prevented illness, as a result of medication had been used not simply to deal with sickness however to induce a extra basic, pleasurable environment of well-being.
This, I believe, is a crucial distinction. Unique medication just like the Goa stone, as an example, had been typically credited with saving the lives of customers who had been poisoned. However additionally it is widespread to see them praised for “dispelling melancholy” or “lightening the spirits” and equally obscure phrases. That seek for a “pleasurable environment of well-being” is, I believe, a deeply underrated side of human nature.
After we discovered in regards to the spice commerce in sixth grade, I bear in mind being instructed that spices had been so beneficial as a result of medieval folks used them to protect meat.
This, it seems, is a myth.
However I believe a part of why its been such a persistent fable is that individuals wish to attempt to discover a sensible, utilitarian rationalization for why so many human cultures over so a few years have valued spices so extremely.
The reality is fuzzier. Personally, I consider spices and medicines grew to become such an necessary component in human historical past as a result of they enlivened on a regular basis expertise — and since they made the patron stand out.
Historians typically deal with the identical idea with phrases like “charismatic goods” or “charismatic substances.” In different phrases, substances like Goa stones had been (and are) not solely seen, however consumable differentiator signaling social and cultural standing. They had been manifestations of mimetic desire.
A part of why I’m a historian of each science and medicines is that they’re linked forces in world historical past. The starvation for spice and medicines helped to create persistent commerce networks. These, in flip, allowed for the long-distance transmission of concepts — and the travels of particular person folks.
The exceptional Arcadio Huang (1679-1716) is one such individual. Huang’s 1701 sea voyage from a port in China to London, after which to Rome and Paris, adopted the identical Indian Ocean routes that had been established two thousand years of spice and drug retailers. I might be writing extra about Huang and his fascinating story subsequent week.
• If you happen to missed it, I wrote about the deep history of psychedelic drugs in one in all my earliest posts for this text final yr.
• “Is historical past a matter of particular person company and motion, or of discovering and quantifying underpinning buildings and patterns?” (Aeon)
• “As a scholar who researches the historical past of Western fears about human extinction, I’m typically requested how I keep away from sinking into despair. My reply is all the time that studying in regards to the historical past of extinction panics is definitely liberating, even a trigger for optimism… Almost each technology has thought its technology was to be the final, and but the human species has persevered. As a personality in Jeanette Winterson’s novel The Stone Gods says, ‘Historical past will not be a suicide word — it’s a report of our survival.’” (Tyler Austin Harper, writing in The New York Times. This one resonated fairly a bit with my very own latest experiences instructing world historical past).
If you happen to acquired this e mail, it means you signed up for the Res Obscura publication, written by me, Benjamin Breen. I began Res Obscura (“a hidden factor” in Latin) to speak my ardour for the precise expertise of doing historical past. Often meaning digging into historic major sources, in all their unusual glory.
If you happen to appreciated this publish, please take into account forwarding it to pals.